The Imperfectionists by Tom Rachman

Jason Rice: It’s a rare book that makes me want to start it again as soon as I’ve turned the last page.  To say I’ve fallen madly in love with The Imperfectionists is an understatement.  Over the last few weeks this debut novel has surprised and thrilled me, never left my side, and somehow renewed my faith in the daily newspaper.  I’ve even stopped myself from reading this book so I could make it last longer.

The Imperfectionists, or the people who I assume to be imperfect, are in fact that real gems of this story. Characters like Lloyd Burko, who gets this story off the ground, and becomes a beacon for the entire cast, and someone I looked back to every few chapters.  What makes this story so engrossing is the different narrators Mr. Rachman deftly weaves together to form a larger tapestry (despite the fact that every editor and agent I’ve ever come across has told me that connected stories don’t sell).  Lloyd Burko is a down on his luck reporter living in Paris. He’s desperate for a story, and rifles through his son’s life to find one.  It’s these quiet moments of professional desperation that made me want to climb inside this book, and take up a permanent residence among these men and women.

Tom Rachman was a foreign correspondent for the Associated Press stationed in Rome.  A fantastic job  by any stretch of the imagination, and he’s worked for the wonderful International Herald Tribune. When I lived in France in 1992, I read that paper every day of the week.  It’s an absolute must read for any American living abroad.

The Imperfectionists will shock a lot of people, not American Psycho shock, but very much like the moments right after the world realized what a great book Then We Came To the End was, and to be honest, Rachman’s novel is as good as that masterpiece. There’s a moment when Abbey who has the wicked nick name, Accounts Payable, is almost convinced that the man she fired is good enough to sleep with, a moment of sorrow, and pity, hers and the readers, and then it’s gone, but you’re left wondering, and saying to yourself; “God damn this is good shit.”  These individual chapters make up the life of the newspaper, and since it’s a Dial Press book, remind me of Kissing in Manhattan by David Schickler.  It’s a perfect comp, but where Schickler sticks with arrested development, Rachman reaches nearly profound levels of realism through humanity. You’ll fall in love with Ruby Zaga, or the strange Winston Cheung, each person is so close that you can feel their breath on your neck.  In the end the people and the story will blow you away, it’s about a struggling International newspaper and (should be a passé thing to write about, with all this internet talk and electronic book nonsense filling up everyone’s time), it’s people; a sad dog, a rabid reader who is ten years behind on her reading of the paper, and Kathleen, oh Kathleen, she’s so good, so right on and who I think is the most serious character in the book. Shit, it’s all serious, it’s prescient, it’s talking about a medium that you and I take for granted, and I for one buried in the sand years ago as being out of touch. Rachman, in his own fluent and vivid ways shows me just how wrong I was to assume that newspapers are dead. Stop what you’re reading, call your Random House rep and get one of these ARC’s. For those of you not in the business, put it on order at your preferred online retailer.


  • Scott Bailey

    “connected stories don’t sell”? Huh. I guess that “Olive Kitteridge” winning the Pulitzer goes right by these agents and editors. Somebody better tell that to Jhumpa Lahiri, too. I think that short forms are making a solid comeback, right under the nose of the publishing world.

  • Scott Bailey

    “connected stories don’t sell”? Huh. I guess that “Olive Kitteridge” winning the Pulitzer goes right by these agents and editors. Somebody better tell that to Jhumpa Lahiri, too. I think that short forms are making a solid comeback, right under the nose of the publishing world.

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    Scott, every agent I’ve ever talked to (at least 100′s) have told me short stories are a “hard sell”, connected stories even harder. Olive Kitteridge was not Strout’s first book, which is why it got published, she had a track record. And Lahiri had written The Namesake, which is like saying she wrote the bible, everyone read it, so she could have presented her publisher with a roll of toilet paper from her summer cottage in Rhode Island and they would have published it. I don’t know if I can name a few collections that get published every year that don’t have a novel attached to them (sitting on an editors desk waiting to be published a year later). Rumble Young Man Rumble would be a good case in point. BC still hasn’t written his follow up novel, but I hear it’s coming. I think Tom’s book got published because it is so good, so amazing, and he’s a talent that can’t be ignored. Look at Kissing in Manhattan, great book, and a first book, again Susan Kamil is finding and publishing “talent”, regardless of what sells.

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    Scott, every agent I’ve ever talked to (at least 100′s) have told me short stories are a “hard sell”, connected stories even harder. Olive Kitteridge was not Strout’s first book, which is why it got published, she had a track record. And Lahiri had written The Namesake, which is like saying she wrote the bible, everyone read it, so she could have presented her publisher with a roll of toilet paper from her summer cottage in Rhode Island and they would have published it. I don’t know if I can name a few collections that get published every year that don’t have a novel attached to them (sitting on an editors desk waiting to be published a year later). Rumble Young Man Rumble would be a good case in point. BC still hasn’t written his follow up novel, but I hear it’s coming. I think Tom’s book got published because it is so good, so amazing, and he’s a talent that can’t be ignored. Look at Kissing in Manhattan, great book, and a first book, again Susan Kamil is finding and publishing “talent”, regardless of what sells.

  • Scott Bailey

    Well, Lahiri won the Pulitzer four years before “The Namesake” came out, and I at least had never heard of Strout before “Kitteridge.” In fact, I only picked that book up because it won the Pulitzer, and I have a long-term project of reading all the Pulitzer winners in fiction. In truth, I tend to avoid collections and go to novels so I’m not prepared to say anything intelligent (though I pretended to in my last comment, eh?), but as a constant reader of literary fiction it does seem to me that there are more collections coming out these days than there were a decade ago. I don’t know if that’s good or bad; it’s just my perception of the marketplace. If you look PW, there are two or three new collections in each week’s reviews. That seems a pretty high percentage to me. Anyway, I don’t write short fiction much, so I don’t have a high emotional investment in the topic but I’ll look for Rachman’s book when it comes to Elliot Bay or Secret Garden or Square One (my favorite local indie shops).

  • Scott Bailey

    Well, Lahiri won the Pulitzer four years before “The Namesake” came out, and I at least had never heard of Strout before “Kitteridge.” In fact, I only picked that book up because it won the Pulitzer, and I have a long-term project of reading all the Pulitzer winners in fiction. In truth, I tend to avoid collections and go to novels so I’m not prepared to say anything intelligent (though I pretended to in my last comment, eh?), but as a constant reader of literary fiction it does seem to me that there are more collections coming out these days than there were a decade ago. I don’t know if that’s good or bad; it’s just my perception of the marketplace. If you look PW, there are two or three new collections in each week’s reviews. That seems a pretty high percentage to me. Anyway, I don’t write short fiction much, so I don’t have a high emotional investment in the topic but I’ll look for Rachman’s book when it comes to Elliot Bay or Secret Garden or Square One (my favorite local indie shops).

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    There is a reason why those collections get published. Unknown writers, they never get that lucky. It’s like entering a three legged horse into the Kentucky Derby. It seems to me, from what I’ve been told, collections don’t sell. Certainly I see collections all the time, so, umm…they do sell.

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    There is a reason why those collections get published. Unknown writers, they never get that lucky. It’s like entering a three legged horse into the Kentucky Derby. It seems to me, from what I’ve been told, collections don’t sell. Certainly I see collections all the time, so, umm…they do sell.

  • Scott Bailey

    I think there’s still a perception that a collection of stories isn’t as good as a novel. It’s like collections get published when the writer doesn’t have anything else ready and too much time has gone by since their last book, like a “best of” CD or something. Even if this isn’t actually the case (because a ton of brilliant short fiction is being written), it seems to be a hurdle publishers and authors have to get over, and maybe you’re right and it’s going to remain hard for debut authors to get collections published.

  • Scott Bailey

    I think there’s still a perception that a collection of stories isn’t as good as a novel. It’s like collections get published when the writer doesn’t have anything else ready and too much time has gone by since their last book, like a “best of” CD or something. Even if this isn’t actually the case (because a ton of brilliant short fiction is being written), it seems to be a hurdle publishers and authors have to get over, and maybe you’re right and it’s going to remain hard for debut authors to get collections published.

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    There is a perception that collections don’t sell, editors and agents think that people won’t read them. How many people jumped at the Library of Congress reissue of the Carver stories? How many people buy his collections every year? Are the #’s smaller for collections, yes. And yes, I can shake a stick at a million stories that are great, better than great. Toby Wolff, Ford, I can go on.

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    There is a perception that collections don’t sell, editors and agents think that people won’t read them. How many people jumped at the Library of Congress reissue of the Carver stories? How many people buy his collections every year? Are the #’s smaller for collections, yes. And yes, I can shake a stick at a million stories that are great, better than great. Toby Wolff, Ford, I can go on.

  • jonathan evison

    . . . JR, you were raving about another debut recently . . .think it was from fisketjohn . . .what was it?

  • jonathan evison

    . . . JR, you were raving about another debut recently . . .think it was from fisketjohn . . .what was it?

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    Mr. Peanut by Adam Ross.

  • http://threeguysonebook.com Jason

    Mr. Peanut by Adam Ross.

  • http://www.threeguysonebook.com Jason Chambers

    Mr. Peanut is a hell of a book.

  • http://www.threeguysonebook.com Jason Chambers

    Mr. Peanut is a hell of a book.

  • Pingback: The Nervous Breakdown

  • Pingback: The Nervous Breakdown

  • http://atomicdoggy.com Lan Sperling

    Hey, awesome website. I actually came across this on Ask Jeeves, and I am really happy I did. I will definately be revisiting here more often. Wish I could add to the post and bring a bit more to the table, but am just taking in as much info as I can at the moment.

    Thank You

    Dog Toys and Clothes

  • http://atomicdoggy.com Lan Sperling

    Hey, awesome website. I actually came across this on Ask Jeeves, and I am really happy I did. I will definately be revisiting here more often. Wish I could add to the post and bring a bit more to the table, but am just taking in as much info as I can at the moment.

    Thank You

    Dog Toys and Clothes

  • Tim Hepp

    agreed

  • http://www.facebook.com/jasonchamb Jason Chambers

    Hi Tim! That’s a pretty phenomenal book.

  • Pingback: The Nervous Breakdown

  • Pingback: JR’s Pick 10/29/2010 « Three Guys One Book