The Signal by Ron Carlson

The Signal by Ron Carlson will be published by Viking in June. It’s not the sort of book that you’d expect an eastern “city slicker” (JE’s apt description) like me to read. Why not? It’s a mystery and adventure novel set in the wild country of Wyoming. Mack is an inarticulate, ex-rancher who is having problems fitting in. Growing up, he helped his father run a guest ranch. But after his father dies, Mack finds he is too anti-social to be in the hospitality business…too much meet and greet required in that line of work. 

I know how he feels. I’m not much of a people person myself. But if I want to be alone, there is no better place to be than Fifth Avenue. Mack has a different approach…he may not be much of a talker but he is a superior outdoorsman: we find him in the mountains at the opening of The Signal.
He is waiting at a trailhead as the dusk settles for his ex-wife, Vonnie. Every year for the past ten, they have taken this wilderness trek. Now the marriage has collapsed like a rock slide. But they are still friends of a kind and Vonnie has agreed to this one last trip.
You can get a grip on the rocks, the lakes, the fish, the elk, in every chapter of The Signal. Also, a fine sense of why people would want to camp. There are a couple of great scenes where Vonnie and Mack just react to the weather, to cooking simple meals and discovering the world as if it was the first time planet earth was there and they were among the only dozen people who had ever seen it. The wonder that the earth is there and that it’s so beautiful, so wild, as if the words “beautiful” and “wild” were synonyms. Are you reading this JE?
But that’s not the best part of this western story…that’s the backdrop…a complex natural syntax, for the dialogue between Mack and Vonnie…what they are like and why their marriage fell apart and why…they are still friends.
Also part of the best part is a character study of Mack…told in flashbacks, of how his ineptness with people leads to a life as a petty criminal and to having a hidden agenda for this last trip with his ex-wife, who, incidentally, has a new man, a city slicker, in her life.
There’s lots of suspense and action in this tale as Mack reaps the consequences for falling helter-skelter into a life of crime. But what I enjoyed most was how Ron Carlson makes me wonder whether I liked Mack or not…small-time sucker of a crook…but in the mountains…more of a sovereign. Decide about Mack for yourself…you’ll enjoy the challenge. 
Also, Mr Carlson, I’ll make a big concession. The mountains of Wyoming have it beat over Central Park. But city slickers and east-of-the-Mississippi types, don’t think this isn’t your kind of book. One of the reasons I wanted to write this review is to prove you wrong. It’s great storytelling and unputdownable.
-DH
  • Jonathan Evison

    . . . sounds like my kinda book! . . . tim sandlin is another wyoming fella who writes about his land beautifully . . .does this mean you’re gonna read west of here, DH?

  • Jonathan Evison

    . . . sounds like my kinda book! . . . tim sandlin is another wyoming fella who writes about his land beautifully . . .does this mean you’re gonna read west of here, DH?

  • DH

    JE, it sounds like I’m going to climb up on that horse again, even though it threw me the first time. It also sounds like I may be interviewing you a second time.

    That might be neat. The first time we were strangers.

  • DH

    JE, it sounds like I’m going to climb up on that horse again, even though it threw me the first time. It also sounds like I may be interviewing you a second time.That might be neat. The first time we were strangers.

  • DH

    I noticed that a fringe political blog put up a grossly distorted version of my Signal review and left my initials on it. Boy, that is really mean-spirited and underhanded. And they blocked comments so I can’t repudiate the phony version. Welcome to the wild world of blogging, DH. The wildness is acceptable but being unethical is not.

  • DH

    I noticed that a fringe political blog put up a grossly distorted version of my Signal review and left my initials on it. Boy, that is really mean-spirited and underhanded. And they blocked comments so I can’t repudiate the phony version. Welcome to the wild world of blogging, DH. The wildness is acceptable but being unethical is not.

  • nancey

    Wanted to love it because of what you said about it. Found myself disliking this book very much. If I had to read Vonnie say 'Mister' one more time….I'm so sad that I don't like it. sigh. I've NEVER not liked a book you guys have recommended.

  • nancey

    Wanted to love it because of what you said about it. Found myself disliking this book very much. If I had to read Vonnie say 'Mister' one more time….

    I'm so sad that I don't like it. sigh. I've NEVER not liked a book you guys have recommended.

  • DH

    Gosh Nancy, I'm sorry that you didn't like the book. I liked it as a stretch for myself since I am the opposite of an outdoor type. I think the whole story rides on the lead character…if you don't like him then you don't like the book. I found him interesting…and the setting was exotic for me since I have only been out west a couple of times.

  • DH

    Gosh Nancy, I'm sorry that you didn't like the book. I liked it as a stretch for myself since I am the opposite of an outdoor type.

    I think the whole story rides on the lead character…if you don't like him then you don't like the book. I found him interesting…and the setting was exotic for me since I have only been out west a couple of times.

  • DH

    …sorry about missing the "e" in your name! I am answering too fast!

  • DH

    …sorry about missing the "e" in your name! I am answering too fast!